Home Lab

SMART said PASSED with 2,184 uncorrectable errors

The hard drive in my NAS says PASSED. Then you read the attributes:

Attribute Raw
5 Reallocated_Sector_Ct 26
187 Reported_Uncorrect 2184
197 Current_Pending_Sector 0
198 Offline_Uncorrectable 0
9 Power_On_Hours 11198

187 is Reported Uncorrectable Errors: 2,184 of them. Its normalised value had bottomed out at 001. Backblaze tracks it as one of five SMART stats that point to a failing drive, and the overall status still says PASSED.


187 is a lifetime counter

It never goes down, so it can’t tell you whether the drive is failing now or failed once, years ago. 197 is the present-tense one, sectors pending right now, and it was 0. So was 198.

So I tested it, three ways, on the box itself so the network wasn’t the bottleneck:

  • write 8 GB of random data through the filesystem, drop the cache, read it back, compare SHA-256
  • badblocks over every sector of the raw device
  • a SMART long self-test, the firmware’s own full surface scan

All three passed, and none of the counters moved between before and after. Seven weeks later, after copying about 246 GB from a Windows drive onto the NAS, they still hadn’t.


The rule

So:

  • it holds bulk and second copies only: downloads, media, scratch. never the only copy of anything.
  • the SSD is the disk to trust
  • smartctl -t long every few months, and retire it the moment 197 goes above 0 or 5 starts climbing
the same drive, overall and attribute 187overall: PASSED187: 2,184187 is a lifetime counter; 197 is the present197: 0198: 0the rulebulk and second copies only